May 31, 2010

Cheap Chris Pine Too Good to Be True?

Webjon reader, and counterfeit Chris Pine buyer Delia alerted me to the card you see in the scan. Offered at the unbelievably low Buy-It-Now price of $100. I emailed the seller and asked if they guaranteed the card was genuine. They never responded, but unsurprisingly the card was sold via Buy-It-Now very quickly.

Now Delia points out another one has popped up for sale by the same seller. . . using the same scan even!

Let’s see. . . price too good to be true, crappy scan, overseas seller, feedback rating: 2 (no feedback for selling), doesn’t respond to questions about authenticity . . . Hmm. . . that’s at least 5 red flags for a single auction. . . I’d avoid this seller’s auctions like the plague. . . These cards are questionable at best, and very likely counterfeit. If anyone knows the buyer of the first card please let them know!

Thanks, Delia for looking out for collectors out there!

Jon

February 18, 2010

Field Report: Dafoe, Dushku and Carpenter


NonSportsCardForum member JerS86 was kind enough share some questionable cards in their collection.

In these unfortunate collecting days it is great to see collectors continuously reaching out to share their stories and contact other buyers of questionable cards. . .

In looking at the scans JerS86 set, I am in complete agreement. Here are JerS86′s comments as to why the cards were being questioned:

I noticed the Dafoe was fake when I saw what someone on this forum posted about ilovenewyork. It’s the same as the one’s he was selling.

Then, I started looking at all of my autograph cards under a 10x magnifying glass and I pulled out the ones that looked a little too perfect.

I originally suspected the Dushku was a fake when I saw how bold and perfect the signature was. I compared it to all of the Dushku’s I could find on eBay and none of them looked as bold as mine. Also here’s an auction that prooves it’s a fake, same exact signature: eBay item: 360221543215, Seller: whysteve.

The Carpenter signature was also a little too perfect. So, I checked eBay and found the same exact card being sold by ihatehappypeople.

I hope this helps.

The Dafoe and Dushku cards that have been questioned multiple times, but this is the first Charisma Carpenter Veronica Mars autograph I’ve seen a collection question. As you can see the Dafoe and Carpenter autos have the tell tale ‘dots’ at the ends of the lines in the signatures, and the Dushku is an exact copy of several others that have been sold.

I have been hoping to do a detailed analysis of these cards, but I haven’t been able to find the time, it’ll come at some point. Thank you very much to JerS86, hopefully this will have more field reports in the future, with any luck it’ll simply be alerts to eBay auctions, and not about cards that have already been purchased.

Jon

January 29, 2010

More on the Hulk Cards. . .

The guys at Rittenhouse got back to me quickly when I emailed them about collect-er-bills’ Ferrigno’s — the seller didn’t get back to me at all.

I asked plainly if these cards were legitimate, and Rittenhouse’s response was:

Lou kept some of the cards, so it’s possible these are among those. It’s hard to tell otherwise, without seeing the cards in person.

So, it sounds to me like these are not legitimate variants produced/distributed by Rittenhouse Archives. It also sounds like the signatures aren’t guaranteed by Rittenhouse either. . .

Jon

Collect-er-bills — Variants, or something else?

I just noticed these items for sale from eBay seller collect-er-bills (items 260542184759, 220545084108, 260542183799, and 220545084799). . .cool card, I have one in my collection except it doesn’t have this great inscription — or that odd white stripe at the top of the card. . .

Hmmm.

Here is the seller’s entire description — emphasis is mine.:

This is a Lou Ferrigno autograph from the 2008 Rittenhouse Archives The Incredible Hulk movie card set. Lou provided the voice of the Incredible Hulk for the film (as the card indicates on the front). It is a rare variation that is in blue ink and with a “Hulk Smash” inscription. It is in NM/Mint condition. Please note that if you are a collector that uses album pages, this card is slightly larger than normal and may or may not fit. Add this card to your collection today. If you have any questions, send me an e-mail.

I’m not sure what the source of these cards is, or how legitimate they are, but given that they are clearly improperly cut based on the seller’s description as well as the white stripe at the top of the card I’d be asking some questions before buying. In fact I did ask some questions. . . one to the seller and one to Rittenhouse. I’ll let you know what the responses are, but I HIGHLY doubt these were released by Rittenhouse in the same fashion the regular cards were released — if these were released by RA at all. It should be noted, too, that this seller has a number of obviously show signed items up for sale.

Here are scans of the other cards up for sale (notice one is inscribed 2008 and another is inscribed 2009):

On another note the seller has a box of Transformers Armada cards up for sale with an insane buy-it-now price. . .

Here is the description:

This is a sealed hobby box of 2003 Transformers Armada trading cards by Fleer. These boxes are real tough to get nowadays. It may contain one of the toughest sketch cards to get with only 50 in existence or even a Pat Lee autograph card. If you have any questions, send me an e-mail.

Great description, except that the sketches are by redemption, and Fleer went out of business in 2005, so . . . uhh. . . buyer beware. . .

Jon

January 25, 2010

Beware the Franco. . .

This James Franco Spider-Man 3 autograph card just sold on eBay yesterday — sorry for the late notice — I was passing the image around to some other folks, like Steve… the guy who identified the first fake Franco. We agree that this card is questionable and likely counterfeit. It was eBay item 110483015792. I contacted the seller this morning, but haven’t heard a response yet.

The buyer has 0 feedback, which is a little odd as well. . .

At any rate, if you happened to have purchased this card check it out very closely when it arrives.

Jon